We Donated Our Late Father’s Corneas, But They Are Not Suitable for the Recipient. What Should We Do?

Question:

Hello, Rabbi, Our father passed away a few weeks ago. We approved the donation of his corneas, but the hospital informed us that they are not suitable for the recipient and is asking for our instructions. What should we tell them?

Answer:

Hello,

First of all, Yashar koach for your willingness to donate. Sometimes, corneas are indeed not suitable for transplantation, but the desire and readiness to donate are a great merit for both the deceased and the family.

From a halachic perspective, many authorities hold that due to the small size of the corneas, they do not require burial. However, both from an emotional standpoint and a halachic one, it would not be appropriate to simply discard them.

Therefore, the common practice is to contact the local chevra kadisha (burial society), and they will arrange for the corneas to be buried.

Wishing you all the best and happier occasions ahead,
Rabbi Yuval Cherlow
Rabbi Cherlow is the Head of the Ethics Department at the Tzohar Rabbinical Organization.

For additional Reading:

More articles on the subject

Videos

Rabbi Yuval Cherlow On AI and Halacha: I24 News

Articles

Using Artificial Intelligence Systems to Rule Halacha [Abridged Position Paper]

Articles

Shield of Israel – Halachic Principles of Carrying a Personal Weapon for Self-Defense

Articles

Reliability, Proficiency, and Readiness

Articles

Introduction

Articles

Chapter One: Principles of Self-Defense and Lifesaving Using Lethal Force

Articles

Chapter Two: Responsibility and Proficiency When Carrying a Weapon

Another Tzohar for ethics

Videos

Rabbi Yuval Cherlow On AI and Halacha: I24 News

Articles

Using Artificial Intelligence Systems to Rule Halacha [Abridged Position Paper]

Articles

Shield of Israel – Halachic Principles of Carrying a Personal Weapon for Self-Defense

Articles

Reliability, Proficiency, and Readiness

Articles

Introduction

Articles

Chapter One: Principles of Self-Defense and Lifesaving Using Lethal Force

Articles

Chapter Two: Responsibility and Proficiency When Carrying a Weapon

יש לך שאלה לצוות המקצועי שלנו?