Is it Preferable to Save a Convicted Terrorist or My Dog From a Fire?

Question:

Hello Rabbi, Over the past year, we have held many meetings bringing religious and secular people together. In our last meeting, the following question arose: Who should be saved from a fire—a convicted terrorist or my dog? We struggled to answer this question. I would appreciate a response, and thank you in advance.

Answer:

Hello,

It is more appropriate to present the question separately:
Is there an obligation to save a convicted terrorist?
This should be considered independently of the question of saving a dog.

It seems that the halachic position is that even if the terrorist has been sentenced to death, it is the duty of the court or the competent government authority to execute the sentence. However, as long as this has not been carried out, he is still regarded as a human being. This is not because of his actions, as he has acted against the divine image within him, but rather from a fundamental perspective that every person is created in the image of God.

Therefore, he should be saved, and afterward, he should continue to be punished according to law and justice.

All the best,
Yuval Cherlow

Rabbi Cherlow is the Head of Ethics at the Tzohar Rabbinical Organization.

More articles on the subject

כפות ידיים של ילד אוחזות בשתיל

Articles

Not Idol Worship: Environmental Conservation Must Be Part of the Jewish World of Faith

Articles

How Can We Be Happy At This Time?

Articles

Creating a compassionate society for Israel’s newly disabled after the war – opinion

Articles

The mutual respect of true love (Day for the Elimination of Violence against Women)

Articles

The Power of Tears

ידיים אוחזות באקדח

Articles

Why is It Justified to Spill Blood?

Articles

One Should Permit the Use of Sperm of the Deceased, But Not Encourage It

Articles

A Humane Economy: Specifically in Times of Crisis Are We Obligated to Weigh Moral Factors

Another Tzohar for ethics

Articles

פרק טו | פריה ורביה

Articles

פרק טז | הימנעות מבשר

כפות ידיים של ילד אוחזות בשתיל

Articles

Not Idol Worship: Environmental Conservation Must Be Part of the Jewish World of Faith

Articles

How Can We Be Happy At This Time?

Articles

Creating a compassionate society for Israel’s newly disabled after the war – opinion

Articles

The mutual respect of true love (Day for the Elimination of Violence against Women)

Articles

The Power of Tears

ידיים אוחזות באקדח

Articles

Why is It Justified to Spill Blood?

יש לך שאלה לצוות המקצועי שלנו?