Is It Permissible to Lie to Yeshiva in Order to Get a Discount on Tuition?

Question:

I am a student at a Hesder yeshiva in my first year. My family cut off ties with my father for a few months (divorced parents) starting during my senior year of high school and finishing in the middle of this year. My mother has been able to obtain a significant discount on tuition from the yeshiva because of this and now, despite the fact that our father is back in contact with us, the discount is still in force and the yeshiva is not aware of the entire story. I want to note that: I believe that my father has the means to pay for tuition. Even when we were in contact with my father beforehand my father still did not want to pay for *school* tuition. The issue now is that after we have reunited he feels the need to be involved (even financially). My father is not religious and I don’t think he views the “burden” put on him to pay such a high sum each month positively, all the more so to a yeshiva (he respects my choice to learn in yeshiva and does not have religion or anything, and it is clear that our relationship will be ok if he refuses, but his identity with religion is not great and asking him to pay a large sum on something that is foreign to him of which he doesn’t see value seems out of place). I am also concerned about asking him for the aforementioned reasons (especially since I almost haven’t asked for anything and suddenly I am coming with a large request, as well as since I only see him about once a month because I come back from yeshiva once every two weeks to my mother most of the time. Since he lives two hours away our relationship isn’t as close as a normal father and son). On the other hand, I am concerned of stealing from yeshiva and like Mesilat Yesharim writes about theft “even if one performs a mitzvah while they are working, it isn’t considered positively but a sin for him, for a sin cannot become a mitzvah”. Another thing is that I do not think my father will view it as theft like I do, I think he will see the money as ‘wasted’ money because I am already learning in yeshiva for a lower sum and he perhaps will see this as giving the yeshiva a lot more money for no reason. I would really appreciate the help, A yeshiva student who doesn’t know what to do

Answer:

Hello,

Firstly, I am happy that peace is slowly returning to your home, and hope that your family reunites with goodness and pleasantly. Because of my role as a Rosh Yeshiva I am biased when I answer this question. Be aware of this, and assess critically.

In my humble opinion, you are obligated to inform the yeshiva of this, while at the same time beginning a sort of negotiation with the yeshiva regarding the payment under the new circumstances.

Two reasons obligate you:

First is the severe words of the Mishnah at the end of Mesechet Pe’ah regarding one who does not require charity and receives it. Granted this is not the exact same thing – and it is possible that you are defined as worthy, but this would require a new discussion, because the conditions have changed.

Second is the fact that the yeshiva gave you a discount on the basis of certain parameters, and when they change – you are no longer qualified for the original discount, and it is possible that you of course qualified for a new discount in light of the new conditions.

I understand the difficulty of doing so, but it seems to me that this is the right answer in all cases, and for any discount a person gets – from a discount on property tax to discounts for children in preschool.

Is it not so?

All the best and much chizuk for your question and your moral code,

Rabbi Yuval Cherlow

Head of the Tzohar Ethics Center

More articles on the subject

כפות ידיים של ילד אוחזות בשתיל

Articles

Not Idol Worship: Environmental Conservation Must Be Part of the Jewish World of Faith

Articles

How Can We Be Happy At This Time?

Articles

Creating a compassionate society for Israel’s newly disabled after the war – opinion

Articles

The mutual respect of true love (Day for the Elimination of Violence against Women)

Articles

The Power of Tears

ידיים אוחזות באקדח

Articles

Why is It Justified to Spill Blood?

Articles

One Should Permit the Use of Sperm of the Deceased, But Not Encourage It

Articles

A Humane Economy: Specifically in Times of Crisis Are We Obligated to Weigh Moral Factors

Another Tzohar for ethics

Articles

פרק טו | פריה ורביה

Articles

פרק טז | הימנעות מבשר

כפות ידיים של ילד אוחזות בשתיל

Articles

Not Idol Worship: Environmental Conservation Must Be Part of the Jewish World of Faith

Articles

How Can We Be Happy At This Time?

Articles

Creating a compassionate society for Israel’s newly disabled after the war – opinion

Articles

The mutual respect of true love (Day for the Elimination of Violence against Women)

Articles

The Power of Tears

ידיים אוחזות באקדח

Articles

Why is It Justified to Spill Blood?

יש לך שאלה לצוות המקצועי שלנו?